Time to Put Kashmir Issue to Rest
When the British left India, two new independent nations were born – India and Pakistan. The popular belief is that India was partitioned but in real terms it was not the Partition of India but it was Partition of Bengal and Punjab, that too absolutely on irrational grounds. It was claimed that Muslim majority territories will form Pakistan and non-Muslim majority, which included Hindus, Sikhs, Jains or people of other faiths will form India or Hindustan. When Pakistan was created India had more Muslims left behind than the newly formed Pakistan. Besides, there were 584 princely states which were governed by the Maharajas or Princes outside the purview of the direct British rule. Indian sub-continent also had few Portuguese held territories or enclaves on its western coast, including Goa proper, as well as the coastal enclaves of Daman, Diu and the enclaves of Dadra and Nagar Haveli which lie inland from Daman. Neither the British nor the Congress leaders paid much attention to these Portuguese territories but agreed that the princely states would decide for themselves which country they will join after the British left. They also had the choice of remaining as independent princely territories if they decided so. But for security and economic reasons all the princely states including Muslim majority princely state Jammu and Kashmir decided either to join Pakistan or India. While taking the decision the will of the common people was never taken into account. In history common people are always neglected while the rulers make important decisions which affect common people. It was the rulers who decided which way to go. Tripura which included the greater Cumilla, though having a Muslim majority population in 1947 decided to join India. The Portuguese territory of Goa and other enclaves were annexed by India in 1961 with some lukewarm response from Portugal. Similar annexation took part in other parts of India which included Hyderabad. The Nizam of Hyderabad owned 40 per cent of territories of Hyderabad and approached the last Viceroy of India Lord Mountbatten to grant him the right to remain as an independent state which was denied. Hyderabad joining India may not be seen as annexation as the Nizam willingly joined India realizing that due the location of Hyderabad his territory could not function as an independent state. Similar willing or forced annexation happened in Pakistan too, especially in the case of mineral rich Baluchistan and in the Northern part of Pakistan, including Bahawalpur. The people of Baluchistan were never happy with the annexation and wanted to retain its independent princely status or become an independent state. The unrest in Baluchistan still continues with a heavy Pakistani military presence. There are numerous complaints of excesses caused by Pakistan’s military in Baluchistan and gross violation of human rights.
Amongst all these forceful or willing annexation, the issue of Kashmir still remains a contentious one between Pakistan and India. Though Kashmir was a Muslim majority princely state, it was ruled by a Hindu Prince Maharaja Hari Singh. As in the case of other princely states on the eve of departure of the British in 1947, Hari Singh also had the option of deciding whether to join India or Pakistan or continue remaining as a princely independent state. He unilaterally decided to join India under pressing circumstances, as in the earlier cases not taking the opinion of the people of his territory into account. This obviously infuriated the rulers of Pakistan as Kashmir was strategically located with borders with India and China.
Strangely both India and Pakistan appointed two British Generals as their Army Chief in 1947. General Rob Lockhart was appointed as Pakistan’s Army Chief while General Frank Meservy took over the Chief of Army Staff in India. The army chiefs were appointed by both the dominions, Pakistan and India. The overall administrative control, but not the operational control, was vested with another British General, Field Marshall Claude Auchinleck, who was titled the ‘Supreme Commander.’ Even before the partition plan became operational Punjab was in a terrible state of communal riots where thousands of innocent people lost their lives and property as it happened in Bengal in 1946. Maharajah Hari Singh did not want to abdicate his power and so he decided to remain independent as a princely state. Further the Maharajah was aware though Kashmir was a Muslim majority territory it also had a sizeable number of Hindu and Sikh population along with other ethnic minorities. If he decided to join either of the two dominions, there may be a repetition of Punjab tragedy in Kashmir. But Pakistan was getting impatient and learning about the intention of the Maharaja first it armed the Pashtun tribesman and sent them to invade Kashmir. The Maharajah’s ill-equipped and ill-trained militia defence soon began to crumble. In the meantime Pakistani regular forces in the guise of Pashtun tribesman joined the invasion on October 22 in 1947. Sensing the fall of Kashmir to the invaders was imminent, he asked Indian government to intervene. But Indian Prime Minister Nehru declined to intervene before Hari Singh acceded to India which he readily did signing an accession treaty. By this time Maharaja lost approximately one third of his territory to the invaders which currently is known as Azad Kashmir or Pakistan controlled Kashmir.
With the accession of the what remained of Kashmir with India, soon Indian government airlifted regular troops to defend the remaining part of Kashmir what it termed its ‘own territory’ as the Maharaja acceded the princely state to India. The behaviour of the two British Army Chiefs on both sides of the border was lukewarm as they had no orders from the British hierarchy who just left India. It can be said that the first of the four wars fought by the two neighbours remained inconclusive but it is agreed that two thirds of erstwhile princely state, including the Kashmir Valley, Jammu and Ladakh were successfully defended by Indian forces. A formal ceasefire was declared effective on 1st January 1949. Over the years both countries consolidated their gains and protected the borders, which commonly became to be known as Line of Control (LoC). For few years there were UN observers to oversee that ceasefire is honoured by both countries. Currently such observers have become redundant.
When the first hostilities broke out between Pakistan and Kashmir and later India entered the scene, the United Nations Security Council intervened and resolved that the future of Kashmir would be decided by the people of disputed territory through a plebiscite and to ensure that to happen, both India and Pakistan must withdraw from their held territories which never happened. No one sees any such things happening in future.
India adopted its Constitution on 26th November 1949 and came into force on 26th January 1950, thus ending its dominion status and becoming a Republic. Unfortunately Pakistan, though adopted a Constitution in 1956 which came into force on 23rd March converting it into a Republic but before the Constitution could actually be implemented, Pakistan tasted its first of many bouts of Martial Law or pseudo Martial Law beginning in 1958 when Pakistan’s President Iskander Mirza abrogated the yet to become functional Constitution of 1956.
As Kashmir was still considered an unresolved issue, Indian Prime Minister Nehru and Kashmiri political leaders negotiated a temporary arrangement to be incorporated in the Constitution which came to be termed as ‘Temporary provisions with respect to the State of Jammu and Kashmir’. (Article 370) The Article included six special provisions for Jammu and Kashmir. It exempted the state from the provisions of the Constitution provided for the governance of all the states. The state was allowed to have its own Constitution. The state parliament would have legislative power only over three subjects – defence, foreign affairs and communications. But the other provisions of Article 370 of the Constitution were in contradiction with the Article 35A of the Constitution (of India) which says, ‘Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, -(a) parliament (of India) shall have, and the Legislature of a State shall not have, power to make laws…’
Temporary provision 370 of the Indian Constitution is sixty years old. During this long six decades no tangible efforts were made to resolve the Kashmir issue. In the meantime Pakistan has taken advantage of the situation making it a hot bed of militancy and over the last sixty years the sufferings of the people of Jammu and Kashmir on the Indian side have multiplied and hundreds of innocent lives were lost. The State suffers immensely economically which is primarily dependent on agriculture and tourism as in the last sixty years because of legal and security reasons no major investments were made in the state, thus denying it any pinch of development as happened in other states of India. Governments have come and gone but peace in Kashmir remained elusive. To the outside world it resembles a besieged territory. Pakistan though regularly sends or arms militants across the border does not also seem to be serious in solving the issue peacefully. It very well knows it cannot afford to go into another war over Kashmir and both India and Pakistan must now have realized that it is high time that the ground reality be taken into cognizance. Pakistan also currently has the Taliban at their door in Afghanistan waiting for US troops to leave Afghanistan.
On 6th August 2019, the Government of India revoked the special status granted to Kashmir under Article 370 of the Indian Constitution. The President of India issued an order under the power of Article 370, overriding the prevailing 1954 Presidential Order and nullifying all provisions of special powers of the State. (In 1954 President Rajendra Prasad issued an order under Article 370 of the Constitution extending to the State of Jammu and Kashmir such modification as were agreed upon Delhi Agreement. This Agreement was entered after a long negotiation between Indian Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and Kashmir’s political leader Sheikh Abdullah while drafting the Article 370 to be incorporated into the Indian Constitution). As of now Article 370 has not only been abrogated but also the State of Kashmir has been bifurcated into Kashmir and Ladakh and declared as Union Territories. Bangladesh has declared these as internal matters of India.
The decision to abrogate Article 370 is fait accompli and the government of India seems to have acted as per their Constitution though the general inhabitants of Kashmir may not have welcomed it. Now the ball is in the Indian government’s court. It should soon end the Union Territory status of Kashmir and Ladakh and give them the status similar to other states of India. It should have its own Lok Sabha with rights to nominate members to Rajya Sabha along with all the privileges and rights of other states of India. The people of Kashmir and Ladakh should be treated with honour and dignity they deserve as citizens of an independent nation and all politicians taken prisoners in recent and previously on political grounds should also be unconditionally released. The people of Kashmir must also realise the geo-political reality, the happening across the border in the so called Azad Kashmir controlled by Pakistan and what is good for their well-being. The first priority that the government of India needs to take is to ensure safety of life and property of the people of the territory or the state and ensure that the children get the right type of education and all sorts of human rights are protected. There is no alternative to winning the hearts of the people and that needs goodwill and patience. The people have suffered for sixty years; now they deserve better deal as free citizens of a free country. Finally both India and Pakistan must realise that the impasse and stalemate over Kashmir will not end through any sort of war or violence but only through peaceful negotiations without the intervention of any third party. This is the only pragmatic solution. Let good sense prevail and let humane approach to solving political problems get a chance.
The writer is an analyst and a commentator.











